Onboarding: Use curated list of XMPP Providers (Category A / B) #588

Closed
opened 7 months ago by Echolon · 1 comments
Echolon commented 7 months ago
Collaborator

Hello,

Here is my suggestion to make use of the curated server list from the XMPP Providers project.

Transparency: Yes, it is another project where I am involved in.

The advantage is that it can simply be read via JSON and, that's what I highly recommend, can make use of guiding users directly to the right support address if they have one of those domain. It can also offer many other options, as randomized distribution of user but also allocation based on e.g. users choice by country / suggestions based on IP / device language. We can also automatically register the user to the relevant support chat / or admin JID. This can also value the idea of federation.

If you clone the repository and run the script you get three categories. Category A has the best ranking and also only list servers which support IBR (in-band registration). The output lists only list the servers and no details, but if it is of interest to make use of some details, those need to be exported as well.
Bear in mind that the C lists might have servers with bad properties of any kind. So I do not recommend to take the bare list. I do explicitly not recommend to use the category C list for onboarding of users.

Also happy to hear your feedback to the project. Let me know if there are technical questions.

UWPX registration

Hello, Here is my suggestion to make use of the curated server list from the [XMPP Providers project](https://invent.kde.org/melvo/xmpp-providers). *Transparency: Yes, it is another project where I am involved in.* The advantage is that it can **simply be read via JSON** and, that's what I highly recommend, can make use of **guiding users directly to the right support address** if they have one of those domain. It can also offer many other options, as **randomized distribution of user** but also allocation based on e.g. users choice **by country** / suggestions based on IP / device language. We can also automatically register the user to the relevant support chat / or admin JID. This can also value the idea of federation. If you clone the repository and run the script you get three categories. **Category A** has the best ranking and also only list servers which support IBR (in-band registration). The output lists only list the servers and no details, but if it is of interest to make use of some details, those need to be exported as well. Bear in mind that the C lists might have servers with bad properties of any kind. So I do not recommend to take the bare list. **I do explicitly not recommend to use the category C list for onboarding of users.** Also happy to hear your feedback to the project. Let me know if there are technical questions. - There is already a first [implemenation at the UWPX client](https://github.com/UWPX/UWPX-Client/pull/159) ![UWPX registration](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/11741404/123478279-83d3ba80-d5ff-11eb-85fb-858a7c462b6e.gif) - To improve automation [placement to xmpp.net is planned](https://github.com/xsf/infrastructure/issues/14) - [Another inspiration from Kaidan](https://www.kaidan.im/2020/01/08/Easy-Registration/)
Echolon added the
Enhancement
label 7 months ago
Owner

Nice idea, I'm willing to implement this for version 3.1.0

Nice idea, I'm willing to implement this for version 3.1.0
kriztan added this to the 3.1.0 milestone 7 months ago
kriztan closed this issue 7 months ago
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Milestone
No Assignees
2 Participants
Notifications
Due Date

No due date set.

Dependencies

This issue currently doesn't have any dependencies.

Loading…
There is no content yet.